Current Value of a Benelli M4 Super 90 (2026 Price Guide)

The Benelli M4 Super 90 stands as a pinnacle of semi-automatic combat shotgun design, renowned for its reliability and adoption by military forces worldwide. As a premium firearm, its value is influenced by a unique set of factors, from its specific model designation to its legal configuration in your state. Understanding these key variables is crucial for any owner looking to accurately price their M4 for a private sale or trade-in, ensuring they receive a fair market offer for this iconic weapon.

What Determines Your benelli m4 super 90’s Worth

The value of a Benelli M4 Super 90 is primarily determined by its specific model, condition, and legal configuration. While the manufacturer’s suggested retail price is around $1,899, the average market price for a new model often settles near $2,043. The most significant value differentiator is the model variant, such as the standard M4 Tactical versus the more collectible M1014 military version. Furthermore, its NFA status plays a critical role; the standard 18.5-inch barrel model is a non-restricted long gun, but versions with a 14-inch barrel are classified as Short Barreled Shotguns (SBS), which are subject to stringent NFA regulations and command a different market value due to their rarity and legal complexity.

2026 Price Breakdown by Generation

Standard M4 Tactical

The value of a Benelli M4 is assessed more by its specific model variant and features rather than by distinct production generations, as the core design has remained remarkably consistent. The standard civilian M4 Tactical model is the most common version found on the market. In the used market, these shotguns typically command a price between $1,600 and $1,800, depending heavily on their cosmetic condition, included accessories, and the number of rounds fired. Its unwavering reputation for durability ensures that even well-used examples retain significant value, making it a stable asset for owners and a desirable purchase for buyers.

Factors that influence whether a specific M4 Tactical falls on the higher or lower end of its value range include the presence of the original box and paperwork, any included choke tubes, and the overall cosmetic state. A firearm with minimal signs of wear will naturally fetch a price closer to the $1,800 mark, while one with visible scratches or dings from heavy use may fall closer to the $1,600 baseline. Local market demand and the completeness of the original package are key considerations for any seller aiming to maximize their return on this highly respected shotgun.

Law Enforcement (LE) Models

Benelli M4 models designated for law enforcement often command a higher price than their standard civilian counterparts, with values typically approaching the $2,000 mark. These versions may include features not found on all commercial models, such as specific sight configurations or stock types, which can make them more appealing to discerning collectors and tactical shooting enthusiasts. The perceived professional-grade status and potential scarcity of LE trade-in models on the open market contribute directly to their elevated value. A seller with a verified LE model should highlight these distinctions to attract buyers willing to pay a premium for the enhanced features and provenance.

The availability of these law enforcement variants is often more limited, which naturally drives up demand and pricing. If the history of a particular LE shotgun is known and can be documented, this can add another layer of value. Buyers are often interested in the story behind a duty weapon, and this uniqueness can be a powerful selling point. Consequently, these models not only hold their value well but can appreciate over time, especially if they remain in excellent functional and cosmetic condition after their service life, making them a solid investment for the right collector.

M1014 Military Model

The Benelli M1014 model holds a special place in the lineup and is widely considered the most collectible variant, a factor that significantly elevates its market price. As the official military version adopted by the U.S. Marine Corps, its direct martial heritage gives it a unique appeal that the standard M4 Tactical cannot match. Collectors and military enthusiasts are often willing to pay a premium for the M1014, particularly for examples that feature the correct “M1014” markings and the original fixed-position skeletonized stock. This historical significance is a primary driver of its higher value compared to other models in the Benelli M4 family.

For sellers, the key to maximizing the M1014’s value lies in its originality and completeness. An M1014 with its original box, manual, and all factory-included accessories will command the highest price. Any modifications can potentially detract from its collectible status, unless the original parts are included in the sale. Because of its desirability among a dedicated segment of the market, the M1014 not only sells for more than a standard M4 but also tends to be sought after more aggressively by buyers looking to own a piece of modern military firearms history, ensuring it remains a top-tier asset.

Short Barreled Shotgun (SBS) Models

Benelli M4 models factory-equipped with a 14-inch or 14.5-inch barrel are classified as Short Barreled Shotguns (SBS) and fall under the purview of the National Firearms Act (NFA). This classification fundamentally changes their market dynamics and value. The legal transfer of an SBS requires an ATF Form 4, a $200 tax stamp, and a lengthy background check process, which significantly narrows the pool of potential buyers to those willing and able to navigate these federal regulations. This complexity is a major factor in any transaction involving one of these firearms, impacting both the timeline and the process of the sale.

Despite the regulatory hurdles, factory Benelli M4 SBS models are exceedingly rare and highly coveted by serious collectors and NFA enthusiasts. Their scarcity often results in a market value that is substantially higher than that of the common 18.5-inch models. The sale of an M4 SBS is a specialized transaction where the seller can command a premium price, but they must be prepared for a sale process that can take many months to complete. The value is driven by rarity and desirability, making it a unique and high-value asset for owners who possess one.

How Modifications Affect Value

When it comes to modifying a Benelli M4, the impact on resale value is heavily dependent on the quality and type of upgrade. Value-adding modifications typically involve high-quality, reputable components that enhance the shotgun’s performance. For instance, installing a premium red dot sight from a top-tier brand like Trijicon (RMR, SRO) or Aimpoint (T2, ACRO P2) is highly likely to increase the firearm’s resale value. Pairing such an optic with a quality mount, such as those made by Scalarworks, further solidifies this value increase, as these are desirable upgrades that a potential buyer would otherwise have to purchase and install themselves.

Conversely, some modifications have a neutral or even positive effect where they might be expected to hurt value on other firearms. Aftermarket triggers, for example, are not generally considered to detract from the Benelli M4’s worth. These are often installed to improve trigger pull or for 922r compliance, making them a practical enhancement. In some cases, a highly modified M4 with a quality aftermarket trigger can be part of a package valued significantly higher than a stock model, especially if the original parts are included with the sale. This demonstrates that thoughtful, high-quality modifications can be a net positive for the shotgun’s market value.

Regional Price Variations in 2026

The value and legality of a Benelli M4 can vary significantly based on state and local laws, creating distinct regional price variations. In restrictive states like California, the M4 is legal only if it does not have both a pistol grip and a telescoping or folding stock simultaneously; therefore, models with a fixed stock are permissible and in demand. Similarly, in New York State, an M4 with a fixed stock and pistol grip is generally legal, provided the magazine capacity does not exceed seven rounds. These legal nuances mean that compliant configurations will command a stable or premium price within these states, while non-compliant versions are virtually unsellable.

The pricing differences become even more pronounced in jurisdictions with stricter local ordinances, such as New York City. The city’s laws define a semi-automatic shotgun with a pistol grip as an “assault weapon,” making this common M4 configuration illegal. To be compliant in NYC, a version with a traditional-style stock is necessary. This creates a niche market where specific, compliant models are highly valued, while standard tactical models cannot be legally possessed. Sellers in or near these regions must be acutely aware of these laws, as they directly dictate the marketability and ultimate value of their firearm.

Online vs Local Sales

When selling a Benelli M4, the choice between an online and local sale involves different logistical and legal considerations. For a private sale, paperwork requirements are dictated by state and local laws, which can vary widely. While federal law does not require a bill of sale for private transactions, it is a highly recommended document. A bill of sale provides a crucial legal record of the transaction, detailing the firearm’s serial number, the date of sale, and the information of both parties involved, offering protection for both the buyer and the seller long after the firearm has changed hands.

Selling online introduces the complexity of shipping. As of 2022, private sellers are prohibited from shipping firearms via UPS and FedEx, as these carriers now only accept such shipments from Federal Firearms License (FFL) holders. A private individual can, however, use the United States Postal Service (USPS) to ship a long gun like the Benelli M4. The firearm must be unloaded and properly declared, and it can be legally sent to a resident of the seller’s own state or, more commonly, to an FFL holder in any other state to facilitate an interstate transfer for the buyer.

The primary trade-off between these sales methods is convenience versus profit. Selling to a local gun dealer is fast and simple, but dealers typically offer between 50% and 70% of the firearm’s used retail value. For a desirable model like the Benelli M4 Tactical, the trade-in value is estimated to be around 65% of its private party value. A private sale, whether local or online, will almost always yield a higher price for the seller, but it requires navigating the associated paperwork, shipping rules, and communication with potential buyers, which demands more time and effort.

The FFL Buying Advantage

Utilizing a Federal Firearms Licensee (FFL) is not just an advantage but a legal necessity for most firearm sales, particularly those conducted across state lines. According to federal law, to sell a firearm like the Benelli M4 to a buyer who resides in another state, the seller must ship it to an FFL in the buyer’s state of residence. This ensures the transaction is compliant and secure. The buyer must then visit the FFL, complete the required ATF Form 4473, and pass a NICS background check before they can legally take possession of the shotgun, providing a layer of safety and accountability.

The role of the FFL extends beyond interstate transactions, as some states mandate their involvement in all private firearm sales, even between two residents of the same state. This requirement ensures that every transfer includes a background check, preventing firearms from falling into prohibited hands. While this adds a transfer fee and an extra step to the process, it offers peace of mind and legal protection for both the seller and the buyer. For a seller, using an FFL for any transaction removes liability and confirms the buyer’s eligibility to own a firearm, which is a significant advantage.

What Increases Your Offer

To maximize the offer for your Benelli M4, professional presentation through high-quality photography is essential. Use a simple, uncluttered background with soft, even lighting from a natural source like a window to avoid harsh shadows. Stabilize your camera or smartphone with a tripod to ensure every photo is sharp and clear. Capture the shotgun from various angles, including detailed close-ups of any markings, the receiver, and specific features. Modern smartphones are more than capable of this task; setting the camera to a 1:1 aspect ratio can help your images fit perfectly into the square formats common on online marketplaces.

Before taking photos, a thorough pre-sale cleaning will significantly boost the firearm’s appeal. Field strip the M4 and meticulously clean all major components, such as the bolt, gas pistons, barrel, and any included choke tubes. It is especially important to remove carbon buildup from the A.R.G.O. gas system to show that the shotgun has been well-maintained. A common mistake to avoid is over-lubricating the magazine tube; this area should be kept clean and dry, as excess oil can attract dirt and grime, which may be a red flag for knowledgeable buyers inspecting the firearm.

Finally, confidently highlight the shotgun’s renowned durability. A high round count does not significantly lower the value of a Benelli M4, as the firearm is famous for its longevity and robust construction. As long as the shotgun has been properly cared for and remains in good cosmetic and functional condition, its value is not substantially impacted by usage. Emphasize its maintenance history and overall condition rather than worrying about the round count, as informed buyers understand that these shotguns are built to withstand extensive use and will prioritize its current state over its past.

When to Sell Your benelli m4 super 90

Timing the sale of your Benelli M4 can have a direct impact on the final price and the speed of the transaction. For a versatile shotgun like the M4, which appeals to both tactical shooters and some hunters, one of the best times to sell is in the months leading up to hunting season. Listing your firearm from late summer into early fall allows you to target the large market of hunters who are actively preparing for the upcoming season. During this period, demand for all types of long guns increases, creating a seller’s market where you are more likely to receive your asking price.

Another prime window for selling any firearm is during tax refund season, which generally runs from February through April. This is a period when many potential buyers have a significant amount of disposable income and are looking to make large purchases they may have put off during the rest of the year. The influx of cash into the market often leads to a surge in firearm sales, and a high-end shotgun like the Benelli M4 is an attractive purchase for enthusiasts with a fresh tax refund in hand. Listing your M4 during this time maximizes your exposure to buyers with the means to purchase.

To optimize your sale, consider the M4’s dual appeal. It is not strictly a hunting firearm, but its reputation and semi-automatic action make it a desirable option for various shooting disciplines. Therefore, a seller can benefit from both seasonal trends. By targeting either the pre-hunting season rush or the tax refund spending spree, you place your firearm in front of the largest possible audience of motivated buyers. Avoiding market lulls, such as the post-holiday season, and focusing on these peak periods is a sound strategy for achieving a quick and profitable sale of your Benelli M4.

Common Pricing Mistakes

One of the most frequent pricing mistakes owners of modern firearms make is paying for a professional appraisal when it is not necessary. For a standard production Benelli M4 Super 90, a formal appraisal is generally not worth the cost. Its market value is not a mystery and can be readily and accurately determined by researching recently completed sales on popular online forums and auction websites. This data provides a real-world baseline for pricing, making a paid appraisal a redundant expense that cuts into the seller’s final profit. Appraisals are better reserved for truly rare, antique, or heavily customized firearms.

Another common error is improperly accounting for cosmetic condition. While a market consensus on a specific monetary penalty for scratches or wear is not available, sellers often misjudge its impact. Some may ignore significant finish wear and overprice their shotgun, leading to a lack of interest, while others might undervalue a pristine example. The best approach is to be transparent and objective. Accurately describe and photograph any cosmetic blemishes and price the firearm fairly based on its condition relative to others on the market. Buyers appreciate honesty and are more likely to make a reasonable offer on an accurately described firearm.

Failing to consider the value of the complete, original package is a mistake that can reduce your final offer. While there is no established consensus on a specific financial penalty for missing items, a Benelli M4 sold with its original box, manual, factory choke tubes, and any other included accessories will always be more appealing, especially to collectors. Lacking these items can lower the perceived value and may cause some discerning buyers to pass on your listing. To maximize your price, gather all original components before listing the shotgun for sale, as a complete set suggests a well-cared-for firearm.

Market Outlook for 2026

While a specific, data-driven future price prediction for the Benelli M4 is not available, its market outlook for 2026 remains exceptionally strong. The shotgun’s value is anchored by its prestigious reputation as the chosen firearm of the U.S. Marine Corps and numerous other military and law enforcement agencies globally. This pedigree creates a sustained demand among civilian consumers who want to own a firearm proven to perform under the most demanding conditions. This enduring legacy suggests that the M4 will continue to be a highly sought-after shotgun, holding its value far better than many of its contemporaries in the tactical market.

The core design of the Benelli M4, centered on its ultra-reliable A.R.G.O. (Auto-Regulating Gas-Operated) system, has remained largely unchanged, a testament to its effectiveness. This design consistency means that even older models are not functionally obsolete, allowing them to retain a high percentage of their original value. Barring any unforeseen, sweeping changes in federal or state firearms legislation that could impact the semi-automatic shotgun market, the Benelli M4 is poised to continue its trajectory as a premium firearm that represents a stable and solid investment for its owner, with demand expected to remain robust through 2026 and beyond.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does a high round count hurt my Benelli M4’s value?

A high round count does not appear to significantly lower the value of a Benelli M4 Super 90. This firearm is renowned for its exceptional durability and longevity, having been designed to withstand rigorous military use. As long as the shotgun has been properly maintained and remains in good cosmetic and functional condition, its value is not substantially impacted by usage. Potential buyers who are familiar with the M4’s reputation understand that it is built to last, and they will typically prioritize overall condition and maintenance history over a specific round count when assessing its worth.

Is it worth getting my Benelli M4 professionally appraised?

For a standard used Benelli M4 Super 90, a professional appraisal is generally not worth the cost. As a modern, current-production firearm, its market value can be readily and accurately determined by researching completed sales on online forums and auction sites. This public data provides a reliable snapshot of what buyers are currently willing to pay. Professional appraisals are more critical and cost-effective for rare, antique, or heavily customized firearms where the value is not easily established through simple market research, making it an unnecessary expense for a standard M4 owner.

Will adding an aftermarket trigger lower the resale price?

Aftermarket triggers are not generally considered to hurt the resale value of a Benelli M4 and, in some cases, may even increase it. These components are often installed to achieve 922r compliance for modifications or simply to improve the trigger pull, both of which can be seen as positive attributes by a potential buyer. In documented sales of highly modified M4s, an aftermarket trigger was part of a package valued well above a stock model. To maximize appeal, it is always recommended to include the original factory trigger with the sale, giving the new owner the option to revert to the stock configuration if they choose.

How much less will a dealer offer me compared to a private sale?

When selling to a gun dealer, you can expect to receive a significantly lower offer compared to a private sale. Dealers typically offer between 50% and 70% of the used retail value for a firearm. For a desirable model like the Benelli M4 Tactical, the trade-in value is estimated to be around 65% of its private party value. While selling to a dealer is faster and involves less hassle, this convenience comes at the cost of a lower payout. A private sale will require more effort but will almost certainly result in a higher net profit for you.

Does the M1014 model really sell for more than a standard M4?

Yes, the M1014 model, which is the designated military version of the shotgun, is often considered more collectible and typically commands a higher price than the standard civilian M4 Tactical. Its direct connection to the U.S. Marine Corps gives it a historical significance that is highly appealing to collectors and military firearms enthusiasts. This added provenance, often accompanied by unique markings, means that buyers are frequently willing to pay a premium for the M1014, making it the most valuable variant in the Benelli M4 lineup, assuming it is in comparable condition.