How Much is an Ithaca Shotgun Worth?

Why Do Gun Owners Like Ithaca Guns?

In the rich history of American firearms, Ithaca Gun Company occupies a unique place, especially known for its high-quality pump shotguns. Founded in 1883 in Ithaca, New York, the company’s shotguns have been the choice of presidents, police departments and hunters alike. Ithaca pump shotguns are renowned for their reliability, smooth action, and superior craftsmanship. These firearms have a long-standing reputation for durability and are often passed down through generations.

Being an integral part of America’s hunting and shooting culture for over a century, Ithaca shotguns have seen action in both World Wars, cementing their place in firearms history. Ithaca pump shotguns, with their perfect blend of form, function, and history, remain a beloved choice for collectors, hunters, and shooting enthusiasts alike. Each model and variant carries with it stories of innovation, craftsmanship and a bygone era of American gun-making.

How To Determine The Value of My Ithaca Shotgun?

Certain Ithaca shotgun variants are particularly valuable. Here are some of the most sought-after Ithaca shotguns:

  • Ithaca Model 37: Derived from a 1915 patent by John Browning, the Model 37 has been in production for more than 80 years, making it the oldest shotgun model still in production. Variants made before WWII or those with unique features (like the Deerslayer or the DSPS for police) can be especially valuable.
  • Ithaca Model 87: Essentially a reintroduction of the Model 37 in the 1980s after the company’s brief hiatus, the Model 87 continued the legacy of its predecessor. Limited runs or special editions of the Model 87 can be more sought after.
  • Ultra Featherlight: As a lightweight version of the Model 37, the Ultra Featherlight is favored by hunters and outdoorsmen who value ease of carry.
  • Special Editions & Engravings: Over the years, Ithaca has released shotguns with special engravings or commemorative editions, celebrating milestones or notable events. These can fetch premium prices, especially if they are in pristine condition.
  • Riot and Trench Shotguns: During WWII, Ithaca produced trench and riot shotgun versions of the Model 37 for the U.S. military. These military versions, distinguishable by their heat shields, bayonet lugs, and markings, are of particular interest to collectors.

The value of an Ithaca shotgun, like all collectibles, is significantly influenced by its condition. Original, unaltered shotguns with matching serial numbers, retaining their original finishes, and showing minimal signs of wear tend to fetch higher prices.

Ithaca shotguns with a high percentage of original finish, sharp markings and minimal alterations or repairs are particularly desirable to collectors. If more usage is apparent, the value will lower with each imperfection. The more scratches and faded finish that becomes present on the gun from handling and usage can greatly diminish its value. The takeaway is that as the condition of the firearm worsens, the less it will be worth when re-sold.

Sell Your Ithaca Shotgun Now with Dunlap Gun Buyers

All we need to make an offer on firearms is a few pictures representative of the gun’s condition and a brief description of the specific make, model and caliber to give an accurate offer and fast cash for guns.

With Dunlap Gun Buyers, we cover shipping, transfer fees, insurance and all other associated costs buying from customers who use our service. We work hard to analyze market trends and provide fair and honest prices to our customers using our service. When we buy guns from customers, we help customers every step of the way by keeping constant communication and work hard to pay our customers in lightning speed to provide excellent customer service.

To see what we can offer on your Ithaca shotgun, click here to get the process started