gun buyback vs dealer sale

gun buyback vs dealer sale Guides

December 20, 2025

Gun Buyback Programs vs. Selling to a Licensed Dealer: What Pays More?

You show up expecting “fair money” and realize the offer is a flat gift card, not cash, and not even tied to what your firearm would sell for. That’s…

Categories

Latest Posts

November 5, 2026

How to Sell a Gun in Oregon Legally

Oregon law checked October 27, 2026. General information, not legal advice. You can sell a firearm you lawfully own in Oregon. Under Oregon Revised…

November 5, 2026

How to Sell a Gun in Georgia Legally

Law checked: October 15, 2026 You can legally sell a firearm you own in Georgia. Under Georgia Code § 16-11-172, background checks apply to firearm…

November 5, 2026

How to Sell a Gun in Florida Legally

General information, not legal advice. You can sell a firearm you lawfully own in Florida. Florida Statutes §790.065 applies its background check to…

November 5, 2026

How to Sell a Gun in California Legally

Legal information checked September 16, 2026. General information, not legal advice. You can sell a firearm you lawfully own in California. Under…

Cash My Guns

4.9

Based on 2606 reviews

Cash My Guns

4.9

review us on See all reviews

1793575157

Sold several guns with them. Every thing went well start to finish. Will be using them again.

1793237395

Great experience with C.M.G. was a'lil disappointed with 1 offer, but had that firearm privately sold. However, on the lil revolver, they were very fair. Was able 2 drop off locally by appointment only. Highly recommend these guys.

1792545357

I had a great experience selling my gun to these guys, they were friendly, fair, and honest. Offered me a decent price and the money was in my account the next day. Would definitely sell to them again.

1792309423

They take care of everything , very nice to work with with one complaint very very very slow paying you after it sells it has been over 3 weeks since my gun sold and no payment ...sad

1791673446

Great service. Polite, professional and responsive staff. Thank you!

1791672566

This was a good experience. The staff was knowledgeable and friendly. I feel I received a fair price for my guns and, with direct deposit received my money quickly. I will definitely do business with them again.

1791373771

1791343583

In general it was easy and straightforward. A little surprise after the packages had been received and acknowledgement that they were as described, but then told they were being inspected. All turned out fine, but the last little step could’ve been handled a little better.

1790872852

First-time customer. My interactions with Cash My Guns were very positive. CMG kept me informed throughout the process. I received significantly more for my firearm than I anticipated and did not have to concern myself with the transactions that followed the bidding closure.

1790785391

I recently sold my firearm to Cash My Guns and had a great experience. The process was straightforward, communication was clear, and payment was received promptly as promised. The transaction was professional from start to finish, and I would not hesitate to do business with them again. Highly recommended.

1790458034

1789671423

They were very easy to deal with. Very efficient and made my experience very pleasant.

1789191492

Great to deal with. Fast and Courteous.

1789166573

Very easy to deal with. Excellent communication throughout the process. Gave me a fair estimate of what they expected them to sell for and, happily, both sold for more than expected. Superfast payment. I highly recommend and would use again.

1789083746

Had a great experience. Reasonable offer and quick turnaround. Communication was professional and courteous. Highly recommended.

1787865765

The experience was one of the best online. They were in constant communication throughout the process, making it a smooth transaction from beginning to end. I would highly recommend them without hesitation as being fair and honest.

Altair Rodriguez Montes

1787831444

100%

1787750134

This is an excellent company to sell your guns to. I have sold two to them recently and plan to sell more in the future. Their website is easy to use, their email communications are both prompt and thorough in answering my questions. Their price quotes re fair and the payment for the purchase is fast. All in all, a thoroughly professional company to do business with!7

1787436133

Overall good experience slight misunderstanding regarding quote.

1787423865

They were great to work with fast devision and prompt payment.

1787265540

Fast easy transaction great service !!

1786824960

Gave us a thirty dollar bonus than other places, very nice to work with.

1786645448

The team at Cash My Guns did a outstanding job handling my guns, from start to finish, they took care of everything.The guns sold for what they had estimated the value to be. I was very pleased.I would use them again. RM

1785007743

The purchase process was easy, and the payment was fast. I would use again in the future

1784754025

Excellent experience. Fair price given. Expedient payment. Easy process.

1784490839

.First class service . Patrick addressed all issues , concerns and questions related to completing the sale transaction. I highly recommend Cash My Guns service that they provide.

David J Gomez Jr

1783368661

Overall great selling experience.. best in town fair and professionalism at its finest, I would highly recommend this place to any firearm seller.. great job Dan

1783117479

Geoff Cornelius

1783095472

Easy process. Submitted pics, received reasonable quote. I am local to location and they made dropoff arrangements outside regular business hours to accommodate my schedule. Quick payment. I highly recommend.

1783042342

it was quick, the price was fair, the process is simple

1782061764

Great process!!! Fair assessments!!! Fast!!

1781520969

1781057790

Cash my Guns was an easy experience. They’re a great company to deal with. They’re very helpful and knowledgeable if you have any questions during the process. I would recommend them to anyone who wants to sell a firearm.

Stephanie Hatfield

1780588770

Excellent people to work with! Fast, efficient service!

Charles “Charlo” Mouton

1780587643

Excellent! I was skeptical at first with the nature of online sales, but the experience was smooth and I received a fair offer! Shall definitely use again if needed. 👍

1780516971

This company is just a pawn shop. They offered $176 for a brand new hellcat pro. The gun was NEVER shot before. Total ripoff. If I took that offer I guarantee you guys would sell it for retail price.

Gilbert Griffith

1780164931

I contacted CFG and sent the pictures. Instantly received a reply, which was courteous and detailed. Then contacted a competitor and received information but not as courteous. Also quite a price with CFG’s to the good. Have a great week. One of the guns was lost by the carrier. CFG rectified the lost fire arm issue. Great service!

1779844542

The staff was very friendly and knowledgeable of my weapon. I received a fair price for my rifle. I would recommend looking up Cash My Guns for a positive experienceR. Quesada

1779307869

Very professional and prompt, and I thought price offered was a fair price.

1778972785

great experience, went very smoothly, great communication

1778708488

Staff was very helpful and friendly. If I had any other guns to sell I would definitely use them again.

1778199076

It was as always a great experience. I dealt with Cash my Guns many times an have always been please. 💯

1777683026

Excellent follow up on all my questions usually within one day. Very good information on the steps in the process.

1777162854

i had inherited an old gun from a family member which was not in the best condition. this place was quick with an offer that i thought was quite good considering the condition it was in. they were up front and honest. the payment was made right to my bank account as soon as they received and inspected the merchandise. i would definitely recommend them.

Michael McMahon

1777052792

Cash My Guns is an easy process and they cover the shipping costs. They communicated the status of my sale and payment. The price was fare and the process was easy. Great service!

1776994630

I've sold or consigned more than 10 guns through Cash My Guns and I'm more than impressed with their service. Now that I've experienced how quickly they work I would probably use the consignment side more often... I think the longest any consignment sale took was about 2 weeks. They are quick to pay, fair, and truly a stand up group of men and women. It's been completely hassle free.

1776556883

One of the best experiences , the process was fast and simple . Great Customer service and pricing

1776006673

Prompt with their responses, fair with their quotes. Very professional group to work with.

1775566736

This is my first experience privately selling a handgun. The process was fair and very easy. I sold a Colt 1911 and a S&W .38 revolver. The price I received for both was 50% higher than my local range offered. I'll definitely use this again!

1775244008

Again, this was a great transaction and appraisal of my firearm…..Looking to continue business with Cash My Guns!